If you have "no place to go," come here!

PPACA FAQ: What is the difference between a tax credit and a subsidy?

Q: What is the difference between a tax credit and a subsidy?

Shorter answer: They apply at different income levels, you may have to pay back the credit but not the subsidy, the subsidy gets directlly credited to the insurance company you pick, instead of being figured at 1040 time, and the subsidy isn't clawed back if your income changes.

Longer answer via Kaiser:

People with incomes between 100 and 400 percent of the federal poverty level ($11,490 to $45,960 for individuals in 2013) may be eligible for tax credits to reduce the cost of their monthly health insurance premiums.

In addition, people with incomes between 100 and 250 percent of the poverty level ($11,490 to $28,725) may qualify for cost-sharing subsidies that will bring down their deductibles, copayments and coinsurance. The subsidies also reduce the maximum amount they can be required to pay out of pocket annually for medical care.

Instead of waiting until tax time to claim the credit for the premiums on their return, people can apply to get it in advance, based on their estimated income for 2014. In that case, the state health exchange, or marketplace, will estimate the tax credit and send it directly to the insurer.

But there’s a catch. When April 15 rolls around, the Internal Revenue Service will reconcile the amount of the advance payments sent to the insurer with the taxpayer’s actual income. If a person’s income is higher than the estimate, the taxpayer will have to repay the difference.

But there’s some good news, too. If a person’s income is lower than estimated, the taxpayer will get a credit.

People who quality for the cost-sharing subsidies won’t face the same financial risk. The federal subsidies, which reduce consumers’ out-of-pocket costs, will be paid directly to insurers....

But with the subsidies, if a person’s income changes during the year, he or she won’t be responsible for any extra costs.

“It’s not a reconcilable tax credit, so consumers aren’t on the hook if their income changes,” says Christine Monahan, a senior health policy analyst at Georgetown Health Policy Institute’s Center on Health Insurance Reforms.

So complicated.

NOTE Of course, none of this complicated rigamarole would be needed with single payer. Single payer Medicare for All gets the middlemen out of the way so the health care system can get on with the business of delivering care. On the downside, single payer doesn't given employment to thousands of trainers, accountants, tax specialists, brokers, or navigators, all of whom exist only to manage the completely unnecessary complexity ObamaCare deliberately creates. It's as if we're congratulating ourselves on buying bug spray for an infestation we should never have had to begin with.

No votes yet


katiebird's picture
Submitted by katiebird on

I know what you're talking about and even I don't get it.

Oh! But, the income verification thing. That's gone. So this all comes down to the Tax Return for 2014 -- which is 1 to nearly 1.5 years after you do that initial estimate of your income for 2014.

Do you suppose this Super Duper Invisible System will send us an email of our Income Estimates?

I asked this question at the Twitter Hangout*

And They actually answered:

Here's the applicable part of the page they're linking:

Modified adjusted gross income
When you fill out the Marketplace application, a number called “modified adjusted gross income” (MAGI) will be used.

Modified adjusted gross income is generally your household’s adjusted gross income plus any tax-exempt Social Security, interest, and foreign income you have. It’s used to determine your eligibility for lower costs on Marketplace coverage, and for Medicaid and the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP).

You don’t have to figure out this income yourself. The math will be done for you when you apply through the Marketplace or your state agency.

For Medicaid, it also matters if you’ve had a change in household income since your last tax return. When you apply you’ll need to tell us your household income now and also estimate the amount for 2014, taking into account changes that you know about.

The HILARIOUS part about that answer was that my question was asked after I followed that link when they gave it as an answer to someone else!!

The REASON I asked it is because. .... MAGI. Really? They're just popping THAT on us in the Middle of October? It is insane.

I wasn't kidding -- we're all going to need HR Block (or whoever) to calculate our income just like we do at tax time. Why would this be any different? Virtually the same penalties apply.

If this is an example of the sort of help Navigators are going to give -- "How do I estimate my taxes?" answer, "Just do the best you can" .... that's totally stupid.

* Lambert, They are answering more questions -- I saw another answer to you and there may be more. I stopped when I saw this one.

Submitted by lambert on

We should do that for next week?

As for the subsidy vs. tax credit thing, what I understand is the difference between the two. What I didn't understand is why one kicks in and not the other. It seems to be a choice , but where is it offered?!?!?

Submitted by lambert on

Just wanted to ping you on that post concept. I'm on at NC this weekend....