If you have "no place to go," come here!

Now Nashville, TN handled its Ferguson protests

Ben Swann:

Chief Steve Anderson, who made news in October when his department refused to cooperate with Secret Service agents who asked Nashville police to falsify a warrant so that they could search the home of an Obama critic, is making headlines again for his unique approach to dealing with protesters angry about a grand jury’s decision not to indict Ferguson, MO Police Officer Darren Wilson in the shooting death of unarmed African-American teen Michael Brown. Rather than confronting protesters with militarized hardware, tear gas, and rubber bullets, Nashville police treated the protest more like a parade or community event, essentially providing security while protesters made their statement.

Incidentally, the protests, though they were emotionally-charged and attended by 450 people, did not descend into the type of violence, rioting, and looting that has been seen in other cities. Said Chief Anderson, “We had people that took to the streets, took to the forums to express their thoughts, their ideas, and they were extremely well-behaved. We had no incidents of any vandalism of any violence of any type. What I noted [is] that people were even picking up the trash that they had left behind at the scene.”

Chief Anderson’s police force met protesters with hot chocolate and bottled water, rather than tear gas, marched alongside them, and ran the type of security that one might expect in a civic parade, communicating on an ongoing basis with protest leaders. At one point, protesters charged up an on-ramp and took over Interstate 24 over the objections of Nashville police. Chief Anderson made a controversial real-time decision, opting not to arrest protesters, and ordered officers to shut down I-24 temporarily, allowing demonstrators to make their statement by lying down on the roadway while drivers waited. Consequently, protesters were cleared off the roadway within twenty to twenty-five minutes. Anderson acknowledged that the incident did inconvenience Nashville drivers, but no more so than a car accident or other situation in which police sometimes block the roadway to protect citizens’ safety.

“We could have moved in and made arrests, but to do that you have to do that one by one in a very careful manner… We would have been there two to three hours,” said Chief Anderson, explaining his decision not to arrest protesters for taking over I-24 in comments to WKRN-TV 2. “Last night’s event went very well and I hope that all of Nashville is proud of not only the law enforcement response, but the response of the citizens involved and that we have set an example for the nation.”

Well, I'm not a Ghandian. So I don't view Anderson's approach as good in itself. I would rather the protests scale up 'til Anderson's strategy can't deal with it. What we're seeing in response to the alternative approach in Ferguson is two commissions, both of which I venture to predict will come to nothing. Block I-24 with a barbecue tent and hold a trial of Wilson along with food! Bring in the streamers and let Anderson try to deal with that.

No votes yet


Cujo359's picture
Submitted by Cujo359 on

Anderson's approach to dealing with protests should be an example to other police forces, Ferguson's and St. Louis County's in particular. This all started because, if one believes the most police-friendly reports, an officer let a manageable situation get out of hand to the point where he had to shoot someone. Then the rest of the police in the area showed that it wasn't just one officer who had poor judgement.

I understand your point about the protests not being big enough, though. I wonder how big they'd have to be. All that protesting back in the '60s doesn't seem to have gotten us out of Vietnam much faster. The Army was reportedly near mutiny back then. It certainly had suffered considerably thanks to the war, and I think that had more of an effect on our politicians' view of the war effort than what most citizens wanted.

What I think that says is that things will have to get a lot uglier before they change for the better. Wishing for protests big and disturbing enough to be effective strikes me as an example of that curse "May your wishes be granted".

Submitted by lambert on

I think they have to be strategic. What is suburban America but malls and freeways? So where are the St Louis protesters holding die-ins? Exactly there.