Corrente

If you have "no place to go," come here!

Dear Democrats, Liberals, Progressives, Bloggers, and other White-Hatted Ones [and this goes for you journalists too]:

If you're going to do opposition research, do this much --

  • get the facts
  • don't tell lies

Paul Kane, reporter [!] for the Washington Post writes at their blog The Trail:

Palin Slashed Funding for Teen Moms
By Paul Kane
ST. PAUL -- Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin, the Republican vice-presidential nominee who revealed Monday that her 17-year-old daughter is pregnant, earlier this year used her line-item veto to slash funding for a state program benefiting teen mothers in need of a place to live.
...

and the news travels over the pond to the UK:

Sarah Palin: Is she the worst running mate in history?
By Anton Antonowicz In St Paul, Minnesota 4/09/2008
RACE FOR THE WHITE HOUSE 2008: First she reveals teenage daughter is pregnant, then McCain confesses he's only met her once, now she's exposed for cutting teen mum aid
...
She's been branded the worst running mate in history - and things are threatening to blow out of control for "hurricane Sarah" Palin.

The Republican vice-presidential hopeful has come under fire since it was revealed her unmarried 17-year-old daughter is pregnant.

But now it has emerged Palin has SLASHED funding for organisations which help teenage mothers.
...
Palin's five-months' pregnant daughter Bristol was with her mum at the Republican Convention in Minnesota last night.

But other expectant teenagers in her situation will be badly affected by legislation passed by the Alaskan governor back in April.

Despite becoming a surprise grandmother herself, Palin agreed to reduce funding for Covenant House Alaska by more than 20 per cent, from $5million to $3.9m.

And the New York Times, in their blog The Caucus starts off just like the rest of them:

Palin’s Budget Cuts Affect Teenage Mothers
By Catrin Einhorn
“Our house is full, help us build a new home,” proclaims the Web site for Covenant House Alaska, a program that helps younger people, including teenage mothers. The Alaska legislature decided to allocate $5 million in building funds, but Gov. Sarah Palin cut that to $3.9 million with a line-item veto in June.
...

And off around the blogs it went -- Sarah Barracuda, Mom Of A Pregnant Teen, Slashes Funding For Everyone Else's Pregnant Teens !1!eleventy-one!1!1!!

--------------------------------

What Really Happened

Covenant House is a faith-based organization that started in New York City and, in spite of a scandal involving its founder, has been the organization taking care of runaways and homeless teenagers for 40 years now, and doing a darn good job of it too, from all accounts. There's even a book about it [apologies for not providing an MCB Sunday Morning Review!].

Covenant House Alaska runs four facilities in Anchorage --

  • Passage House, a transitional living program ... [that] provides young mothers a place to live with their babies for up to eighteen months while they gain the necessary skills and resources to change their lives
  • Rites of Passage, a transitional living program that offers a unique opportunity for homeless youth (ages 18 to 20) to address the issues and responsibilities of adulthood while receiving residential support and the guidance of Covenant House Alaska staff and volunteer mentors
  • a Community Service Center, that provides a whole host of services such as counseling, tutoring, job assistance, health care, a legal clinic...
  • and a Crisis Center, whose doors are open 24/7/365 to provide immediate short-term shelter [average length of stay in 2007 = 15 days] for kids who are in immediate need and have nowhere else to go.

It's the last facility on that list, the Crisis Center, the immediate short-term shelter, that Covenant House Alaska wants to expand, so they applied for a grant from the state of Alaska, asking for $10 million to help build a new, larger facility in a more central part of Anchorage. The state legislature, in an overall appropriations bill, voted to give them $5 million in fiscal year 2009 towards the project, and Governor Palin used her powers of line item veto to cut that amount to $3.9 million. Alaska, for all its corruption alleged and actual, posts much of its business online. You can read the final [massive] appropriations bill for fiscal year 2009 here, and even find the justifications for each and every line item veto here [item 318, on page 21].

-- Just as an aside, I'd like to point out that this kind of transparency is one of the many benefits of socializing such things as health insurance. You won't get anything like that kind or amount of information from the for-profit insurance industry. --

For a bit of perspective, Covenant House Alaska helped a total of 3165 kids, 1334 of whom utilized the to-be-expanded Crisis Center [nb: 24,625 meals served] and 12 of whom were teen moms or moms-to-be living in the not-going-to-be-defunded Passage House.

So, all this could just as easily [and much more accurately] have been labeled Governor Palin Awards $3.9 Million To Help Alaska's At-Risk Youth !1!eleventy-one!!!1!

I haven't found a corroborating source for this yet, but apparently Covenant House Alaska has issued a press release:

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
September 4, 2008
Contact: Deirdre A. Cronin
Executive Director
907-339-4203

“Covenant House Alaska is a multi-service agency serving homeless and runaway youth, including teen mothers. The majority of the agency’s annual operating budget is privately raised, with no more than 10 to 15 percent of funds coming from state grants in any given year. We are grateful for the support we have received from Governor Sarah Palin, the Alaska legislature and our Congressional delegation over the years.

Despite some press reports to the contrary, our operating budget was not reduced. Our $3.9 million appropriation is directed toward a multi-year capital project and it is our understanding that the state simply opted to phase in its support for this project over several years, rather than all at once in the current budget year.
...”

I wonder if that will show up in any media outlets or blogs.

--------------------------------

Finally, to give credit where credit is due, and to encourage the casting of aspersions where they're due, I'll note that the NYT blog post I quoted above does have this paragraph, down near the end of the post [emphasis added] --

While teen pregnancy has dropped across the country, its decrease is even more dramatic in Alaska. According to the most recent figures from the National Campaign to Prevent Teen and Unplanned Pregnancy, the pregnancy rate for girls 15 to 19 in Alaska showed a 33 percent change from 1992 to 2000, the third largest drop in the country. Stephanie Birch, maternal and child health director with the state department of health, attributed the drop to increased access to birth control and guidance from health care providers through an expansion of rural and community clinics and public health centers.

What Democrats, liberals, progressives, bloggers, and other white-hatted ones really need to be doing is dethroning the Dominionists and demolishing their War On Women. It would help if journalists who get paid to do this stuff would write about it too, but don't expect that to happen.

0
No votes yet

Comments

Damon's picture
Submitted by Damon on

Sorry for the distraction, but this has to be a new record. The Mirror piece by Anton Antonowicz mentions Bristol Palin being pregnant at least three times in just seven paragraphs. That is nothing short of amazing, to me.

Really, you can't make this stuff up. Sorry, again, for the sideshow.

Submitted by hipparchia on

especially when they draw attention to stupid people being stoopid, and that article was a stellar example of the genre. no apologies needed.

intranets's picture
Submitted by intranets on

"After 15 straight years in decline, the U.S. teen pregnancy rate rose by 3% from 2005 to 2006."

I looked up the stats, because I always hate when they only cite percentage change. All the cited statistics are from.
The Alan Guttmacher Institute. (2004). U.S. teenage pregnancy statistics: Overall trends, trends by race and ethnicity and state-by-state information.

One thing that drives me nuts about the study is that women aged 18-19 are also included in statistics on "teen pregnancy", which is technically correct, but doesn't seem as relevant to me.

What will be funny is when the cite more recent studies that show Alaska pregnancy rate on the rise since Palin takes office (eleventy-one indeed!). They will leave out the national trends probably.

peter's picture
Submitted by peter on

Many thanks for your work here on this topic. To use this as a club against her is just awful.

gyrfalcon's picture
Submitted by gyrfalcon on

I posted on this a while ago in comments here somewhere, though not in as much detail, and it was discovering this particular, um, falsehood, distortion, whatever, that caused me to start questioning many of the "facts" about Palin being circulated on blogs and in the MSM and start digging around in the ADN archives and elsewhere for first-hand quotes.

I found that almost all of the most widely cited "damning" pieces of info about Palin on what I guess we call cultural issues is false, except for her stand on abortion, and a number of others just tell half the story.

She's pro-contraception, not anti.
She's *for* sex education in the schools, not for "abstinence only."
She's not for replacing evolution with creationism in the schools, just doesn't think it should be forbidden to discuss creationism if the question is asked in science class
She *didn't* say the Iraq war was "a task that's from God," she asked a church group to "pray that it's a task from God"

On and on and on and on.

I've got the links and cites on these somewhere, and I can dig them out later if people want them. Or you could the research yourself. It's not that hard to find. Start with a post on Time's Swampland blog today or late yesterday, which has a link to a video of one of the gubernatorial primary debates she participated in.

I normally don't give much credence to conspiracy theories, but it seems to me it's way too much of a coincidence that all these false talking points about Palin appeared practically simultaneously. It smells to me very much like well-prepared oppo research. The most obvious source would be the Obama camp, despite their clearly phony claim to have been taken by surprise by her nomination. But geez, I hope they wouldn't stoop to this level of smear.

Could also have been some outside pro-choice or Dominionist watch group, but the instant acceptance of these "facts" by MSM without further checking makes me think it's somewhat more likely to have been a source with some level of established credibility with MSM.

I hope I'm totally wrong on all of that.

In the meantime, nobody seems to be seriously digging in real detail into things like her dealings with the oil companies, the pipeline negotiations, her actual relations with Stevens et al, or even really the "bridge to nowhere" stuff, which she keeps quite forcefully claiming she said "No thanks" to Congress about and appears to have done no such thing. (Yes, there's been plenty of superficial "debunking" of this claim, but Palin is clearly not such a phenomenally stupid bald-faced liar to say this repeatedly on the national stage without some sort of justification in mind, and nobody, as far as I can tell, has even tried to find out what that might be so we can evaluate it.)

And I really don't wnat to get into an argument about whether such tactics are justified in defeating her and McCain. I went through too many endless bull sessions on that kind of question in the '60s and '70s. I don't like being lied to, no matter who's doing the lying and for what purpose.

Bryan's picture
Submitted by Bryan on

This is a variation on the "tax increase" tactic that the Republicans use all the time, i.e.
voting against a tax cut equals voting for a tax increase.

With all of the manure being spread you would think that Governor Palin has never done anything truly objectionable in office.

Submitted by gob on

With all of the manure being spread you would think that Governor Palin has never done anything truly objectionable in office.

When somebody tells lies in the service of one side of an issue, I tend to assume they couldn't find any attacks based on the truth. So they've just argued in favor of the other side, in effect.

Policy not party!

Submitted by jawbone on

aggregating all this information in one easy to cite place. I've been commenting about this particular MCM and Blogger Boyz (and Grrrlz) falsehood in several places, comparing it to the lies told about Al Gore and noting how those lies have lived long beyond the Gore candidacy and even long after they've been rebutted.

I fear the same will be happening with the Sarah Palin mistaken and misleading (lying, OK?) reporting.

I hated it and tried to fight it when it was done to Gore (and the Clintons, Kerry, other Dems), and I hate that "my side" is now doing the same thing in league with the MCMers*.

On Bill Moyers' Journal last Friday, Kathleen Hall Jamison tried to knock down one of the false reports about Palin (this one?), but how many people actually watch his great program? Not our "vaunted free press" MCMers!

*MCMers--Members of the Mainstream Corporate Media

Paul Krugman kept me from going insane during the Gore campaign (Conason and Lyons helped as well, with some great NPR reporting [one great piece from This American Life putting the lie to the WaPo and NYTimes reporting that Al Gore claimed to have "discovered Love Canal," a false report which still has legs]), as at that time I had no internet access. Later, lefty blogs helped. It is so incredibly disappointing to see that second lifeline to reality now falling prey to the ease of propaganda through the Big Lie.

What has happened to the Reality-Based Community??

lillianjane's picture
Submitted by lillianjane on

I think we have to maintain a standard for journalism whether it seems to favor "our side" or not. Certainly there is enough to criticize about Palin without exaggerating or outright lying. I think the press should aspire to something higher than urban legend.